TruckingIndustry.news

Findings of Morgan Crash Don't Just Blame the Truck Driver

by Jana Ritter - Published: 8/12/2015

After nonstop coverage of the crash that severely injured celebrity Tracy Morgan and killed fellow comedian James McNair in June of 2014, the National Transportation Safety Board finally revealed the findings of their investigation at a public hearing on Tuesday. They ruled the Wal-Mart truck driver’s fatigue as the chief cause of the crash, but also said that unused seatbelts and the poorly trained emergency responders exacerbated the injuries. The investigators also pointed out that the customized limousine left the six passengers without any available exits and forced the emergency responders to cut out part of a plywood panel that had been installed between the passenger compartment and the cab, which delayed medical attention.

                                                        NTSB hearing

In other news
January 05, 2018 - Trucker Faces 20 Years After Pleading Guilty To Smuggling Alien Found Dead In Locked Toolbox
January 02, 2018 - Police Identify 2 Oregon Truck Drivers Killed In Fiery Head-On Crash
December 27, 2017 - Iowa First Of Eight States To Debut New Truck Parking Information System

“Their single means of exiting had become inoperable in the crash,” Christopher Hart the board chairman said at Tuesday’s Washington hearing. The officials also said even if that sliding door had worked, it was above passengers’ heads after the accident caused the van to flip onto its side. If the vehicle had caught fire, the passengers would have been trapped and basically burned alive.

                                                         Findings of Morgan Walmart Crash

Still, officials found truck driver, Kevin Roper, to be the root cause of the accident as he had been traveling 65 miles per hour in a 45 mph construction zone and failed to slow down as he approached the backed up traffic. He rear ended the van and set off the deadly chain reaction. While Wal-Mart has since settled wrongful death suits with Morgan and the victims’ families, Kevin Roper is still awaiting trial on criminal charges of vehicular homicide and assault by auto. Investigators also ruled that fatigued driving and violating the HOS rules were also factors likely contributing to the truck driver’s failure to respond when approaching the construction zone. At the time of the crash, he had been awake for more than 28 hours and had already driven 800 miles overnight from his home in Georgia to a Wal-Mart distribution center in Delaware, where he began the delivery.

                                                          Walmart driver Kevin Roper

However, officials didn’t solely blame the truck driver for what resulted in McNair’s death and Morgan’s severe brain injuries. They said that the outcome was also due to a lack of training with the medical response team. According to safety board investigator, Thomas Barth, the medical workers initially “failed to recognize how serious the situation was and how many severely injured occupants” were in the van. By the time more highly trained medical workers arrived, “they were overwhelmed,” because “they didn’t have enough resources on hand,” Dr. Barth explained. It took an entire 40 minutes for responders to extricate the passengers, which is a crucial amount of time lost in a situation requiring urgent medical attention.

Investigators concluded that the incident revealed communication problems between medical teams dispatched from different jurisdictions, with different levels of experience. They board suggested that New Jersey set uniform training standards for groups that provide emergency medical service on the turnpike.


Lynnwood Edward Sonnier
Lynnwood Edward Sonnier
It's still not walmart fault. What a driver does on his time off or his commute is not their issue. He has only been on duty a couple hours!
Trucking Unlimited
Trucking Unlimited
They determined he had been awake for more than 28 hours driving from his home in Georgia just to get to the distribution center in New Jersey.
Lynnwood Edward Sonnier
Lynnwood Edward Sonnier
Still not walmart problem. What a person does on his time off is his decision. If I take my 10 hour break and don't go to sleep it's not my employers responsibility
Trucking Unlimited
Trucking Unlimited
That may be true, but they already agreed to major settlements with the victims and families.
Lynnwood Edward Sonnier
Lynnwood Edward Sonnier
To avoid the bad publicity. I think they should have fought it. All they did was taught every lazy dicksucker in the country that walmart is a easy target
Brett Gottfried
Brett Gottfried
he worked for walmart, so yes it is on them too!
Lynnwood Edward Sonnier
Lynnwood Edward Sonnier
No its not. They did nothing illegal. They were within the law
Mike Kimball
Mike Kimball
It doesn't matter if Walmart, the company, did anything wrong, the Walmart driver did, so Walmart, the company, is liable.
Colby Metcalf
Colby Metcalf
Ignorant people. The driver is at fault. No one held a gun to his head. I haul cattle ain't no load or other people's lives worth losing. I'm sure some of will argue cuz that's all u can do. I confronted a driver in Texas they other day pulled out in front of me I was going 45. I told him he was stupid I was walking back to my truck he jumped out hit me twice back of the head I laughed at him then his girlfriend told him get back into his truck. Yall better start treating others how u want to be treated cuz this Ole dog is about ready to drop fools.
Lynnwood Edward Sonnier
Lynnwood Edward Sonnier
^^^agreed
Paul Person
Paul Person
I retired 3yrs ago, but I took my cb out 5yrs before that! I got tired of the cussing and disrespect. Don't miss all the bs!
Robert W. Day II
Robert W. Day II
It's sad that it happened, and I truly believe that there was poor judgment used. And he's going to live with it, I'm a driver and I hope that other drivers will learn from this unfortunate tragedy.
Dave Huhnerkopf
Dave Huhnerkopf
I've been saying all along this wouldn't have been as bad if they were wearing seat belts. Being rich or famous means nothing when you flip over
William Seifert
William Seifert
I m sure walmart did some influence peddling on that one........
Dave Huhnerkopf
Dave Huhnerkopf
So Walmart influenced the inspectors finding that the seat belts not being used were a contributing factor in the death and injuries? SMH
William Seifert
William Seifert
Searbelts would have been an issue if the D bag steering wheel holder wasnt maxing out his cruise control blasting thru a construction zone like an unproffessional dumb ass Walmart has tons of lobbiests and lawyers effecting the outcome of this accident dont kid yourself.